Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • YouTube

Not Just Cute

Whole Child Development

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Speaking
  • Podcast
  • Books
  • Contact
  • New? Start Here.

The Danger of Performance Hang Ups in Early Education

November 17, 2016 by notjustcute Filed Under: Child Development & DAP, Learning through Play and Experience 3 Comments

A few years ago, the Gesell Institute, named for developmental pioneer Dr. Arnold Gesell, decided to test the premise that kids today develop more quickly than they used to.  They took the developmental norms established by the work of Dr. Gesell in the 1940s and launched a three year study concluding in 2010 to gauge whether or not the same framework still holds up.  What they found, of course, is that even over the span of decades, the developmental norms remain the same.

(Read more about that study and the follow up interview with the director of the Gesell Institute, Dr. Marcy Guddemi.)

While there are many, many quotes from that study’s roll out that caught my attention, one that particularly made me think was when Dr. Guddemi responded to the question of why it may sometimes appear that children are capable of skills beyond their developmental level:

You can train them, but the knowledge and understanding—the true learning—has not happened.  Our country has this hang up that if the child can perform, that they know.”

It was that word, “perform”, that stood out to me most.

It seems we really do have a hang up with performance in our country.  We talk about the importance of getting kids to perform well on assessments and how to make assessments out of performances.  And while I agree that we need to make sure kids are learning and can translate that learning into meaningful, useable, applicable knowledge, I also agree that our cultural hang up with performances can be detrimental.

I remember back in high school, learning a story about a horse named Clever Hans.  Clever Hans became famous in Germany back in the early 1900s.  His trainer believed Hans could answer math problems, calculate what day of the week a date would fall on the calendar, and understand the German language both written and spoken.  All of this he would answer by tapping his hoof to indicate his answer.

People, particularly curious about animal intelligence at that time due to the then-recent writings of Charles Darwin, flocked to watch Clever Hans perform.  This attention eventually spread to a group of scientists who set out to discover if and how Clever Hans had learned all that he seemed to.

What they found was that Hans was certainly clever.

But he wasn’t doing math.

He wasn’t reading German.

He was performing.

The panel of scientists discovered that Hans was using his “horse sense”, so to speak, to perceive the social cues around him and know when he had tapped long enough to arrive at the correct answer.

It was amazing to think this horse was doing complex computations, but a horse’s brain just isn’t wired for that.  Instead, Clever Hans was using his senses to perceive expectations and perform as though he knew.

I worry sometimes that there’s an unwitting willingness to trade real learning for performances.  That instead of working on the foundation, we’re trying to plop down the whole house at once because that’s what people want to see.

We can get children to recite or to perform, but do they know?  Are we trading real, foundational learning for a parlor trick that simply gives the appearance of knowing?

As Dr. David Daniel, psychology professor at James Madison University and managing editor of the journal Mind, Brain, and Education,  stated in the Harvard Education Letter,

The four-year-old has a four-year-old brain and a six-year-old has a six-year-old brain. There are certain things connecting in a six-year-old brain that are still being worked on in the four-year-old brain.”

Getting four year-olds to do what six year-olds once did isn’t necessarily moving forward.  It may be more akin to driving down a freeway that hasn’t been completed yet.

Let’s not get so caught up with performances that we neglect to keep building the roadway.

Top Image.

Clever Hans Image from the Public Domain.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Comments

  1. 1

    Peggy says

    November 17, 2016 at 4:55 pm

    I totally agree. I even remember as a child thinking that I understood
    what I had learned. It wasn’t until much later that the special “Aha” moment
    came with the revealing of the true understanding. It helped me as I taught
    preschoolers for about 22 years .

    Reply
    • 2

      Heide says

      February 11, 2017 at 9:22 am

      i got a C- in my maths and decided about 4 years later to retake as i thought i don’t want this to hold me back if i want university …. by then i was keeping a household and so many of the equations i was expected to do suddenly made sense like as 3 for 2 deals in a supermarket or mortgages etc and i came away with a B+ … i don’t think the study was better or anything like that it was me as a person could apply what was being taught to my life not just as figures on paper. So i would agree with this. i just find it hard now as a parent to not get caught up in the school’s goals for achievement never mind what my children are individually capable of and at what otherwise sacrifice (i.e don’t go play because you need to finish your homework) so i am trying to keep the goal just to enjoy learning be that reading writing or playing in the mud and learning gravity etc!

      Reply
  2. 3

    Mark says

    April 20, 2017 at 11:14 am

    So very true, and it’s evident in more than just school performance. Gladwell pointed out the same connection in young athletes–chronological age had a lot more to do with success than we all thought it did. What is “raw talent” in sports is often mistaken for just having more touches on the ball than anyone else due to an age advantage of 6-12 months.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

search this site

Privacy & Cookies: This site may use cookies to customize your experience. Learn more by reading our Privacy Policy.

I’m Amanda Morgan. Here’s what I’m about…

In early education, there is too much distance between what we know and what we do. I bridge the gaps that exist between academia, decision-makers, educators, and parents so that together, we can improve the quality of early education while also respecting and protecting the childhood experience.

Content Copyrighted (2008-2022), Amanda Morgan, All Rights Reserved

Get Our Newsletter & Developmental Guide

  • Home
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 · Swank WordPress Theme By, PDCD

 

Loading Comments...